Executive disability and life carve-outs: coverage that scales with real compensation.

Group disability and life plans cap out well below what senior people earn. Carve-outs restore the difference with policies the executive owns and keeps — the first structure most companies put above the plan, because the arithmetic is impossible to argue with.

Individually owned · Portable · Sized to real pay
An arched alcove in a limestone wall
01 — The arithmetic

Sixty percent of salary, until the cap.

A typical group long-term disability plan replaces up to 60% of base salaryAnchin ↗ and stops at a monthly cap usually between $5,000 and $10,000Anchin ↗. The table applies a $6,000 cap — the figure in Anchin's example — to four salaries. Everything above the cap is the gap.

How the table is calculated: 60% of annual salary, divided by twelve, compared with a $6,000 monthly cap. Replacement is the lower of the two as a share of salary.
Annual salary60% benefit per monthPaid at a $6,000 capReplacement
$100,000$5,000$5,000 — under the cap60%
$200,000$10,000$6,00036%
$300,000$15,000$6,00024%Anchin ↗
$400,000$20,000$6,00018%

The $300,000 row is Anchin's own exampleAnchin ↗; the other rows apply the same cap and benefit percentage. Bonus, commission and incentive pay are outside the base-salary formula, so for a leader paid partly on results the real replacement ratio is lower still.

Disability coverage calculator

Your pay, your plan's terms, and whether the benefit is taxed. The IRS rule: if your employer pays the premium, you must report as income any amount you receive for your disabilityIRS ↗; if you pay the entire cost with after-tax dollars, don't include any amounts you receive for your disability as incomeIRS ↗. If the cost is shared and you pay your share after tax, only the amount you receive for your disability that's due to your employer's payments is reported as incomeIRS ↗; premiums paid pre-tax through a cafeteria plan are considered paid by your employerIRS ↗. An estimate to start the conversation, not a benefit quote.

17%of your pay would actually arrive each month. 60% of $25,000 a month is $15,000, capped at $6,000 before tax, or $4,200 after an estimated 30% tax. Against $25,000 a month of pay, that is 17%; against take-home pay after the same 30% tax on your pay ($17,500), 24%. The drop from take-home pay is $13,300 a month. The plan's formula counts base salary only.
02 — What a carve-out does

Restore the coverage the cap took away.

An executive disability carve-out is an individual disability income policy issued to a defined group of executives, usually with simplified or guaranteed underwriting, owned by the executive, and portable when they leave. It pays on top of the group plan, so the combined benefit tracks real compensation — including the pay the group formula ignores.

Life carve-outs work the same way above the group life multiple: individual coverage, individually owned, sized to the person rather than to the plan's median.

One carrier's description of the aim: “close the income protection gap for high-earning employees in key leadership roles, so coverage scales with their compensation, and their financial confidence remains strong enough to keep their talent with you”Guardian ↗.

And the reason it belongs first: “executives who rely only on standard group benefits are likely to be underinsured”Guardian ↗.

03 — Who this is for

Anyone the cap hits.

i.

Partners and principals

Owners who draw well above the group cap and whose household depends on that income continuing.

ii.

Leaders paid on results

Sales leaders, rainmakers and operators whose bonus and incentive pay the group formula never sees.

iii.

The people you want to keep

A policy the executive owns and keeps is a reason to stay that doesn't show up on a pay stub.

04 — Questions

Carve-outs, in plain terms.

All questions

Why isn't the group disability plan enough?

Because it is built around the median employee. A typical plan replaces up to 60% of base salaryAnchin ↗ and stops at a monthly cap usually between $5,000 and $10,000Anchin ↗. Below the cap, the plan works as designed. Above it, the replacement ratio falls with every dollar of income — and bonus and incentive pay are not in the base-salary formula at all.

Does the executive keep the policy?

Yes. A carve-out is an individual policy issued to a defined group, owned by the executive. It stays with them if they change roles or leave — which is part of why it retains people. One carrier's framing: coverage that “scales with their compensation”Guardian ↗.

Who pays?

Either the company or the executive, and the choice affects taxation of the benefit. We model both ways in the exposure review and your CPA signs off on the treatment.

Are group disability benefits taxable?

It depends on who paid the premium, and how. The IRS rule: if your employer paid it, you must report as income any amount you receive for your disabilityIRS ↗; if you paid the entire cost with after-tax dollars, don't include any amounts you receive for your disability as incomeIRS ↗. If the cost is shared and you pay your share after tax, only the amount you receive for your disability that's due to your employer's payments is reported as incomeIRS ↗; premiums paid pre-tax through a cafeteria plan are considered paid by your employerIRS ↗. Most group plans are employer-paid, which is why the calculator above defaults to a taxed benefit — and why a 60% plan can deliver well under half of pay once the cap and the tax are both applied.

Is underwriting required?

Carve-outs are typically issued to a group of executives at once with simplified or guaranteed underwriting, depending on the group's size and the carrier. That is one reason to do this as a group rather than one person at a time.

What does a carve-out plan mean?

A benefit written for a defined group inside the company — the partners, the executive team — on top of the plan everyone else has. In disability and life coverage it means individual policies issued to that group, usually with simplified underwriting, so their coverage tracks real compensation instead of the group cap.

How is Nova HR paid for this?

Carve-out policies are carrier-funded — the commission is built into the premium. The exposure review that sizes them is complimentary.

See the gap for your own leadership team.

The executive exposure review measures group disability and life against each key person's real compensation and prices the carve-out that closes the gap.

Review your executive exposure